Comparison
MetalMetric vs BullionVault
One tracks the metals you already own. The other is where you buy and store allocated bullion. They're fundamentally different tools — here's exactly how.
Updated March 2026 · Feature data verified against live sites
🏠
MetalMetric
Track what you own
Log coins, bars, jewelry, and Goldbacks from any source. See live melt value and P&L. Your metals stay in your safe.
🏦
BullionVault
Buy, sell & store bullion
Purchase allocated gold, silver, platinum, and palladium. Stored in professional vaults in 5 countries. Trade 24/7.
TL;DR
Choose MetalMetric if you already own physical metals (from any source) and want to track melt values, P&L, and manage your collection. Choose BullionVault if you want to buy investment-grade bullion and have it stored professionally in vaults worldwide. They can work together — buy on BullionVault, track everything in MetalMetric.
Where MetalMetric Wins
MetalMetric advantage
MetalMetric shines when you already own physical metals and need to manage your collection. It tracks any item from any source — coins from a local dealer, junk silver from eBay, jewelry inherited from family, Goldbacks from a gun show. You get per-item P&L, tax planning, AI scanning, and a unified view of everything you own. BullionVault only knows about metals bought on their platform.
Where BullionVault Wins
BullionVault advantage
BullionVault is unmatched for buying and selling allocated bullion at institutional-grade spreads. Their peer-to-peer order board, insured vault storage in 5 countries, daily audits, and Queen's Award-winning track record since 2005 give serious investors confidence in counterparty security. If you want to own gold without worrying about home storage and insurance, BullionVault handles it.
Can You Use Both?
Yes — and it's a smart setup. Buy allocated bullion on BullionVault for vault storage, then log those purchases in MetalMetric alongside your coins, bars, and jewelry stored at home. MetalMetric gives you a single dashboard showing your total precious metals portfolio across all sources — with live melt values, cost basis, and P&L for everything in one place.
Track your entire stack in one place
Log metals from BullionVault, local dealers, eBay, or anywhere else. Free to start — no credit card required.
Start Tracking Free →
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between MetalMetric and BullionVault?
▾
They serve fundamentally different needs. MetalMetric is a portfolio tracker — you log physical metals you already own (coins, bars, jewelry, Goldbacks from any source) and it calculates live melt values and P&L. BullionVault is an exchange where you buy, sell, and store allocated bullion in professional vaults worldwide. MetalMetric tracks what's in your safe. BullionVault IS the vault.
Can I use MetalMetric to track metals bought on BullionVault?
▾
Yes. Add any precious metal to MetalMetric's vault regardless of where you bought it. If you purchased gold through BullionVault, add it with the weight, purity, and price paid. MetalMetric tracks its live melt value alongside your other holdings from coin shops, eBay, or any source — giving you a unified portfolio view across all platforms.
Does BullionVault have a portfolio tracker for coins and jewelry?
▾
No. BullionVault tracks only allocated bullion bars purchased through their platform. It does not support logging coins, rounds, jewelry, Goldbacks, or items bought elsewhere. If you own a mixed collection from multiple sources, MetalMetric is built for that use case.
Is MetalMetric free compared to BullionVault?
▾
MetalMetric's free tier includes portfolio tracking for 25 items, all 21 calculators, and live spot prices — no purchase required and no storage fees. BullionVault has no setup fee but charges 0.5% trading commission and 0.12% annual storage (gold). The key difference: MetalMetric charges for premium software features; BullionVault charges for physical custody and trading.
Can BullionVault track Goldbacks or junk silver?
▾
No. BullionVault deals exclusively in investment-grade bullion bars stored in professional vaults. It does not support Goldbacks, junk silver, numismatic coins, or jewelry. MetalMetric supports all of these with native Goldback tracking for 5 states, a junk silver calculator with ASW data, and jewelry tracking by karat.